Photo Courtesy of Azamat Hatypov- Pexels
I can count on my hand the number of times I have heard someone claim that an adaptation, whether that be for the big or small screen, was better than the original book. There are many adaptations that can hold their own and can be considered good in their own right, but rarely are they good adaptations of the work. It is easier in books to provide nuanced details and get into the heads of characters than it is on screen. That is why many adaptations lack the depth that the original book provided.
It is also a struggle to fit all the scenes that occurred within the novel into the adaptation, as there is only a limited amount of time, especially if it is a film. I will always suggest reading the source material first. However, there is one adaptation that stands out from the rest, and that is the film adaptation of the novel Small Things Like These by Claire Keegan.
This novel and thus the film follows the life of Bill Furlong, played by Cillian Murphy, during 1985 in Ireland, a period where abuse in places like Magdalene Laundries were commonplace. Run by the Catholic Church, the laundries housed girls and women sent for reasons like pregnancy out of wedlock, abortion, or mental health issues. They worked there, doing laundry, like slaves. They weren’t allowed to leave and many were abused.
Keegan did a wonderful job exploring the subtleties of life during this time and how systemic abuse of women could go on for years in a society. The novel questions how atrocities like these happen and what is the duty, if there is one, to help the people around you. The film adaptations took these questions and ran with them, making the movie a cinematic masterpiece.
Many other adaptations cut pivotal scenes and change character development drastically. I’m looking at you Percy Jackson & The Olympians: The Lightning Thief (2010) and My Sister’s Keeper (2009). This film however, was taken almost word for word from the novel. There are only a few slight changes between the two, one of them being that the character Sarah Redmond, played by Zara Devlin, was still pregnant with her child in the film; in the novel, she had already given birth. This change was made in order for the viewers to better understand the parallel between Sarah Redmond and Bill Furlong’s deceased mother. It also gave the movie a more hopeful feel, as Sarah would have been able to take care of her baby in the future, while in the novel, her child was taken from her.
The film perfectly articulates the feel of the novel. Through fantastic acting by people like Cillian Murphy, Emily Watson, and Eileen Walsh, viewers are able to see the characters’ feelings through facial expressions and physical body language. This movie is full of emotion, taking the subtle cues within the novel and exploring them deeply. The cinematography is stunning as camera angles alone help the film explore themes like the power of the church.
I have yet to watch an adaptation that has stuck as closely to the novel as Small Things Like These (2024). Being less than a hundred pages, it was easier for the movie to stick closer to the source material compared to others.
The film and novel seem to break your soul and put it back together at the same time. Both show you the atrocities going on in Ireland in the 80s, while also shedding hope for a future where nothing like this ever happens again. I truly recommend reading the book, then watching the movie as the film sheds light on many nuances you might have missed while reading. Also, who doesn’t want to watch a movie with Cillian Murphy in it?