Why Lori Grimes gets too much hate
Photo Courtesy of Céréales Killer- Wikimedia Commons
Picture this: the world has ended and you’re alone with nothing but a young child and the fear you carry forward. All that is left of your old life is in ruins with the exception of your husband’s best friend, who is willing to protect you both like his own. In that situation, it is clear that you would lean on him. That is where Lori Grimes from The Walking Dead (2010-2022) found herself, and she has been vilified for it ever since.
Lori Grimes is complex, and similar to most complex and realistic women in fiction, she is hated. The closest thing she had to Rick were Carl and Shane. As two people who lost someone important, Lori and Shane find comfort in each other. It stops once Rick is reunited with Lori and Carl. Only, Shane is the one who couldn’t stop. He even tried to force himself onto Lori in the episode “TS-19.”
Yet, she gets the worst hate. There’s no accountability for Rick’s best friend having sex with his wife. The wife is solely at fault. There’s no discussion on a perceived widow’s grief potentially being taken advantage of by her dead husband’s best friend. I would argue Lori was in a larger state of vulnerability than Shane.
The whole problem this all boils down to, in my opinion, is that many viewers lack nuance. They say they like grey characters, but really they don’t. They like morally grey male characters. Women have to be good at all times, otherwise they’re horrible. For female characters, there’s only black and white. Take the very instance of two beloved characters: Daryl and Carol.
Daryl made plenty of reckless decisions over the course of the show and was rewarded with his own spinoff. There was even a campaign that if he died, fans would stop watching the show. Then there’s Carol, who is arguably just as morally ambiguous. While Carol is celebrated as she grows from an abused wife into a hardened survivor, she is also called “two-faced” and “psychopathic” for doing the same things Daryl and Rick did. Lori made one choice—to lean on someone while believing her husband was dead—and she became the show’s punching bag.
While as a viewer I was aghast at how quickly they jumped into sexual activity, but I can still understand the reasoning behind it. I don’t think she was ever “starting to fall in love” with Shane as many like to point out. They got together because of the traumatic bond of losing their entire lives. Their relationship and lust were born out of a chemical need for stability, clinging on to the only remains of their previous world.
Traumatic experience bonds within couples and relationships tend to happen when their nervous systems interpret the surrounding chaos and emotional volatility as some form of deep chemistry or passion. This ends up translating survival relief into sexual urgency. It’s the beginning of the apocalypse and no one knows what’s happening. The fear and closeness they already had fueled itself into any form of release they could perform. I assert that Lori and Shane just wanted to escape the pain and suffering, and Lori just wanted to forget the loss she had.
When Rick came back, she made it clear to both of them that she was Rick’s wife first and foremost, making it clear to Shane that she would not be sharing any of her affections.
The fact that he lied to her about Rick, at least in her perspective, and the fact she was hit with that lie in the form of Rick coming back, helped her move on from that situation with Shane fully.
Now, I’m not trying to be a Lori Grimes apologist. She has done her fair share of things, but all characters in The Walking Dead have, both in the show and in the comics. All I’m asking for is consistency. If you’re going to hate Lori Grimes, give a reason that you would apply to Rick, Daryl, or Shane, too. I’m simply stating that the hate she got, and still continues to get, is more or less unfounded. Yes, she slept with her husband’s best friend, but she did other things also. People harp on that as the sole fact of her hatred and then bolster it slightly by saying things like, “she was a horrible mother! Did you see how she let Carl go off on his own?” But every parent in this show made dangerous calls with a child nearby, and none of them were judged this harshly.
She’s also judged for supposedly turning Rick and Shane against each other, which is just blatantly false. She urged Rick to get rid of Shane, yes, but that was from a genuine fear of Shane’s volatility and growing resentment towards the Grimes’ and the survivors as a whole. She was thinking about the good of the people and her family. Rick and Shane were adults, men who could reason and make their own decisions in the world. Lori Grimes wasn’t Lady Macbeth, plotting and scheming and pushing. She was scared, and she was right to be.
Now let’s go back to that opening scenario: the world has ended, you’re alone with a child, and the only person left from your old life offers to keep you safe. Most of us would lean on him. Lori did, and she has been judged for it for over a decade. She was never a saint, and she doesn’t need to be. She was a mother trying to keep her son alive, making the same desperate choices as every other survivor. The only difference is who was forgiven for them.