What can we learn from histories of violence?

Photo Courtesy of Hobi Photography- Pexels

I’ve written for The Lamron in the past about my frustration with a perspective that views our current administration’s policies in a vacuum; I’ve expressed my disagreement with those who talk about current events as “unprecedented.” Specifically, I’ve taken issue with those who view the Iran war as a project tied to President Trump and President Trump only—ignoring or avoiding discussing the long history of our foreign involvement and its implications. 

This semester, I have been taking two classes that have prompted me to think further about this topic—about the way that history seems to repeat itself: one centering on the Vietnam war, and another focusing on two Irish poets (Seamus Heaney and Eavan Boland) who often wrote about violence in the context of the Troubles. As the semester progresses, I find myself returning to the oft-repeated idea about history—that if you don’t study it, you are doomed to repeat it. 

I think this is a bit of an oversimplification that can be twisted to support distorted narratives of history and thus further destructive policies in the present. Relevant to this conversation is an important piece about history that often isn’t actually taught until you leave high school—that constructing it is a project of interpretation. 

Narratives of history are not void of bias. They are not separate from the people that create them. When I learned about the Vietnam war in high school, at no point did I learn about Vietnamese civilian casualties. I didn’t know about our sustained bombing campaigns. I didn’t know about our burning of villages or our use of napalm; I didn’t quite understand what it meant that civilians were deemed indistinguishable from combatants. And, also essentially important, I was never compelled to consider the war from a Vietnamese perspective. 

My understanding of history was incomplete. Voices were excluded and sidelined. Knowing that now pushes me to find the voices I cannot hear today as war is waged once again. It encourages me to seek out views that are not in the mainstream. 

Understanding that the history I learned and the news I read now is not necessarily a complete, singular ‘Truth’ allows for an introduction and acceptance of many other truths. It makes us potentially less susceptible to repeating cycles of violence, as we reject simple narratives that support current actions; it allows us to question the very assumptions that have underpinned how we understand our role in history.

In this sense, I do think it is important to learn history in the hopes that we will know better and be better. But I would add that it is important to understand what history is and how narratives of history have been weaponized in the pursuit of violent political policy. 

I’m not sure if it is realistic to assume that if people did learn from and about history, it would not be repeated, and we could find some form of escape. I sometimes think that human beings will always inevitably be human beings, repeating the same cycles and acting out similar structures of power and violence, of progress and pushback. 

There is also the matter of political efficacy and the power of an individual; I often feel that even if I personally—or we collectively—disagree with a policy project like the Iran war, our voices become irrelevant in the face of a government that is often influenced by wealthy actors more than constituents, and which ignores dissenters in favor of its own aims.

At the same time, it is clear that people in power know the importance of historical narratives—that is why they try so desperately to control them. People in power want to deprive you of your individual sense of agency and make you feel powerless against them. Don’t let them. Choose to believe that your voice matters—and use it to complicate their black and white oversimplifications and challenge their narratives.

Previous
Previous

The Lamron’s favorite qualities

Next
Next

Small Things Like These has the best adaptation