Cam Schlittler has been named the 2026 American League Cy Young
Photo Courtesy of New York Yankees- Wikimedia Commons
After each Major League Baseball (MLB) season, the single most successful pitcher from the American League (AL) and National League (NL) is awarded the Cy Young Award. “From its establishment in 1956 until 1966, it was presented to the best pitcher in Major League Baseball. Since 1967, there is one winner from each of the American and National leagues,” according to Baseball Reference.
This year’s American League Cy Young Award was awarded to not only an incredibly dominant pitcher, but a pitcher in his first full season in the major leagues, as detailed by MLB. Cam Schlittler, pitcher for the New York Yankees, took home the 2026 AL Cy Young Award, which he was voted for unanimously. Schlittler’s unanimous win, along with Jacob Misiorowski’s unanimous Cy Young win this season, as recorded by the Baseball Writers Association of America, marks only the twenty-sixth unanimous Cy Young Award since 1931, when the Cy Young began being awarded, according to MLB.
Cam Schlittler ended his 2026 season, his first full season in the major leagues, with a 1.95 earned-run average (ERA), 239 strikeouts, a 0.92 walks plus hits per inning (WHIP), and a .700 winning percentage, as reported by ESPN. Yankees manager Aaron Boone congratulated the star pitcher on his accomplishment, saying “Cam had as dominant a season as a starting pitcher can have from start to finish,” as quoted by Yahoo Sports. Schlittler joined only two other New York Yankee pitchers to be awarded a Cy Young unanimously: Ron Guidry in 1978 and Gerrit Cole in 2023.
In a video posted to the Yankees’ Instagram account, Cam Schlittler was shown receiving the award, calling it a “special moment” for him and his family. Schlittler specifically praised the advice his father gave him: “hard work is going to beat talent,” Schlittler said. He recounted relying on that advice from high school baseball, to college, to even making it to MLB after not being a highly-ranked prospect, and now winning his first Cy Young Award. However, he is not satisfied yet. As quoted by Yahoo Sports, Schlittler also said, “I definitely could have had a better season…I feel like it’s been a lot of months kind of wondering or having that pressure on me” to win the Cy Young.
Schlittler has already been extremely successful in his young career. He made his first major league start on July 9, 2025, pitching for the Yankees against the Seattle Mariners, as reported by CBS Sports. ESPN documented that the Yankees won that game with a score of 9-6, with Cam Schlittler taking the win. He went on to quickly begin making history in the 2025 postseason with a standout performance against the Boston Red Sox, as recorded by SportsNet. MLB reporter Jeff Passan posted on X about Schlittler’s postseason performance, reporting, “He went eight shutout, allowed five hits, didn’t walk a batter and struck out 12. He is the first pitcher in baseball history to go eight innings, walk none and punch out 12 in a postseason game.”
Schlittler beat other star pitchers Dylan Cease and Parker Messick for the Cy Young award this season, who came in second and third place in voting, respectively, as per Yahoo Sports. Currently, according to Sports Illustrated, Schlittler is under contract with the Yankees for seven more years. However, moves by other teams, such as the Cincinnati Reds, who extended their standout pitcher Chase Burns (who also debuted in 2025) to a 105 million dollar contract extension, may pressure the Yankees to extend Schlittler’s contract earlier in an effort to keep the breakout player in New York.