It is becoming a bit excessive
Photo Courtesy of Markus Winkler- Wikimedia Commons
Podcasts—especially sports podcasts—have recently become extremely popular, and while I love a good sports podcast, not every athlete needs to have one. It seems as though every athlete who has retired, and even those who are active in the league, have taken to starting their own podcast, and most of them are unnecessary.
As a major fan of the Women’s National Basketball Association (WNBA), I will mostly focus on podcasts centered around the WNBA or started by WNBA players. Sports podcasts are terrific when done right, but too often they can become repetitive and boring when every sports podcaster is speaking on the same topics or interviewing the same people. One sports podcast that I truly enjoy is called “Bird’s Eye View,” which was founded by Sue Bird.
This podcast, hosted by WNBA legend Sue Bird, focuses on analysis and features interviews with some of the most-talked-about players in the WNBA. Due to Sue Bird’s experience in the league and retired status, she offers listeners an educated and informative view on the topics she is discussing. I particularly enjoyed her interviews with Paige Bueckers, Jessica Shepard, Gabby Williams, and Natasha Cloud. Sue Bird is also the Managing Director for the International Basketball Federation (FIBA) USA Women’s Basketball team, so her podcasts reflecting on the experience were very insightful.
However, not all sports podcasts are this well-received or wanted. As a fan of Azzi Fudd, I can acknowledge that her podcast, “Fudd Around And Find Out,” fits into that category even though it is enjoyable to watch. The podcast usually features a guest every week, but typically, her co-host Ashanti Plummer is the one asking most of the questions. To me—and this is my opinion—it feels as though this is a weekly FaceTime call between friends; while not necessarily a bad thing, there are too many podcasts similar in nature flooding the market.
When a sports podcast is done correctly, it is one of my favorite things to listen to; when done incorrectly, it feels like a way to profit off of fan dedication. Furthermore, when an abundance of podcasts exist revolving around similar topics, it feels very repetitive and creates a sense of viewer fatigue—especially when some of the athletes hosting these podcasts are not performing up to standard within their respective sport.
Podcasts done incorrectly also lead to platformed hateful rhetoric. Many of these sports podcasts will acknowledge hateful narratives being posted online, and it can lead to those narratives being pushed further. For example, many podcasters have given voice to Angel Reese and Caitlin Clark comparisons and criticisms. This has led to both fanbases attacking each other and provides a sense of validation to online trolls.
However, sports podcasts are a great way to consume sports media when done correctly! Sydney Colson and Theresa Plaisance co-host a podcast called “Unsupervised with Syd & TP,” which has been enjoyable to listen to. These two are best friends, and both have experience in the WNBA, which has allowed for natural banter and insightful conversations.
I particularly enjoyed the episode where they discussed their perspective on Kelsey Mitchell and her future with the Indiana Fever. In her exit interview, Mitchell opened up about the online hate she had received—most likely due to racist fans who claim to support Caitlin Clark—and Colson quickly came to her defense on the podcast. Players—current or former—supporting each other is what sports media should be about. Allow healthy criticism and conversations to be had about the game, but also create a productive podcast.
Athletes being able to profit off of their experiences is not something new, but it has been a consistent issue that these profiting ventures feel inauthentic or lazy. The market for sports podcasts is heating up, and with that, so is the demand for podcasts that are worthwhile.