Dancing with the Stars (2005- ) needs to fix some things

Photo Courtesy of Serecki- Wikimedia Commons

As a longtime viewer of Dancing with the Stars (2005- ), I am more than qualified to comment on the show’s recent misgivings. Whether it be the skewed voting system or the faulty judging, improvement needs to be made. Here are some of the most aggravating aspects of the show:

1. Judging

Judging is one of the most frustrating things about the show and it causes the most issues. As someone who has witnessed Dancing with the Stars (2005- ) employ many different judging systems, the one currently being used does not work—especially combined with the growing popularity of the show. 

The current judging panel—which consists of Bruno Tonioli, Carrie Ann Innaba, and Derek Hough, according to ABC News—does not work. Bruno is always shouting out unnecessary comments and fails to critique the dances, Carrie Ann makes weirdly misogynistic comments and is known to underscore female celebrities, and Derek simply cares too much about being liked. A dream judging panel would consist of Mark Ballas, Kym Johnson, Sharna Burgess, and another qualified member; Shirley Ballas or Julianne Hough could be great options. All of these people have experience on the show and during guest judging stints, have provided insightful feedback and fair scores. 

2. The voting system

The voting system on Dancing with the Stars (2005- ) majorly impedes my enjoyment of the show. Currently, as explained by Entertainment Weekly, fan votes and judging votes are combined to account for who will get eliminated that night. I prefer the system where judges would save someone from the bottom two because that would coincide with the scores and actual dance ability. With this, while fan votes would still have a large impact, contestants would be eliminated fairly off the show. 

Fan votes have too much power right now, as Just Jared explains, which can lead to shocking eliminations and couples making it farther than they should have. When judges pick between the bottom two who go home, it is a much fairer and more entertaining system; that way whoever goes home did so sheerly because of the dance performance—which is what the show is about. 

3. Uneducated fans

Now, I recognize that this is not an issue that the show can necessarily fix. However, if the voting system and judging is rectified, this will not be as big of an issue. The show experienced an increase in popularity a few seasons ago due to social media presence and new pros or celebrities who brought in a lot of attention. While this is great, there have been many downsides to this. 

Many of the newer fans do not understand how the show works or become very annoyed online, circulating hateful rhetoric about couples competing against their favorite celebrity. Recently, fans of Connor Wood have been adamantly stating that he is more improved than fellow contestant Tatyana Ali—which is simply not true from a dance perspective. A majority of newer fans do not seem very familiar with how the show is run and are ruining it with the constant favoritism they bestow onto certain cast members over others. Furthermore, they often push many false narratives that are misogynistic and favor male contestants, such as the aforementioned Wood and Ali argument. 

Overall, this is one of the best shows on air right now and it has been a monumental part of my childhood. For future seasons, the judging and voting systems should be altered to reflect the growing popularity of the show and ensure the competition remains even.

Previous
Previous

Changes in the leaders behind Pixar

Next
Next

Films to anticipate as the year concludes